- Winecious.life
- Posts
- How to Read a Wine Menu: tips, myths, and smart choices in restaurants
How to Read a Wine Menu: tips, myths, and smart choices in restaurants
Learn how to read a wine menu like a pro: common myths about wine markups, and how to choose the right bottle or glass without overpaying
Some time ago, I used to feel uncomfortable with a wine menu in a restaurant. That long list of regions and vintages felt like a secret code, because I could get lost, unsure what to choose, and sometimes ended up ordering a cocktail instead.
Today, with more knowledge and experience, I navigate it with ease, and I want to share some of these insights with you.
Have you ever started to look inside the wine list and picked something random to get it over with? You’re not alone. The good news is, once you know a few simple tricks, that long wine list starts to feel much less intimidating.
Let’s start with the classic question: Should you order a bottle or a glass?
Even a simple by the glass section like this can look confusing at first sight.
The answer depends on the occasion and your plans. If you’re with friends, a bottle usually makes sense, unless everyone prefers different styles, then individual glasses are the better option.
On a date, when you know two glasses won’t be enough, a bottle feels totally right. But if you’re driving or simply not in the mood for more - one glass is the perfect choice.
Once you’ve decided between a bottle or a glass, the next step is understanding the wine list itself.
At first, it might look overwhelming, but it actually follows a logic. Let’s break down the key facts and common myths that will help you read any wine list with confidence.
Facts about Wine Lists
Menu structure helps you navigate
Most wine lists aren’t random. They’re grouped by color (white, rosé, red), region, or style (light, fruity, full-bodied). Once you see the pattern, it’s easier to find something that fits your mood.\
“By the glass” is a good way to explore wines
Perfect if you don’t want a whole bottle or if everyone prefers something different. Some restaurants even offer a taste pour (around 2 oz), so you can sample a wine before deciding on a full glass. It is convenient if you’re curious about something new.\
Sommelier’s recommendations are worth a look
Sections like “Sommelier’s picks” or “Hidden gems” often spotlight wine that combine great value with interesting pairings you might not think of yourself.\
Lesser-known regions = better deals
Famous regions often carry higher prices because of prestige. Wines from neighboring or less famous areas can be just as delicious, often at a friendlier price.\
Half-bottles or half-pours
These smaller options let you enjoy a variety of wines over the course of a meal, without over-ordering or overspending.
🔍 Myths about Wine Lists
“The second cheapest bottle is a trap”
Not always true. Many people believe restaurants inflate the price of the second-cheapest option, assuming guests don’t want to look stingy. In reality, the highest markups are often found in the mid-range, not at the bottom of the list.
\
“Cheap wine means bad wine”
Price doesn’t always reflect quality. In good restaurants, even the most affordable wines are carefully chosen to pair well with food and to represent good value.
\
“Expensive wine is always better”
A higher price may reflect the brand, region, or rarity rather than just taste. Sometimes a less famous producer can offer a more interesting wine at a friendlier price.
\
“Sommeliers push the most expensive option”
A good sommelier wants you to be happy with your choice so you’ll come back. If you share your budget and taste preferences, they’ll often guide you to hidden gems, not the priciest bottle.
For example, once during dinner at a steakhouse, I asked the sommelier for a European bottle in the $150–200 range, not too young, with plenty of red fruit, and a good match for meat dishes. He brought me a Châteauneuf-du-Pape (retail price about $55). It turned out to be one of my all-time favorites, and a reminder that the right choice isn’t always the most expensive one.
\
“Only full-bodied reds are serious wines”
Light whites, rosés, and sparkling wines can be just as complex and impressive. Often they’re even more food-friendly.
🍷 Things to Keep in Mind When Looking at a Wine List
Varietal (grape type) – The grape name tells you a lot about the flavor and style. For example, Pinot Noir is usually lighter with red fruit notes, while Cabernet Sauvignon tends to be fuller, darker, and more structured.
0
Region/country – Geography is a key clue to what’s in your glass. For instance, if you see Bordeaux, expect a blend of Merlot and Cabernet Sauvignon. Sancerre means Sauvignon Blanc, and Chablis is always Chardonnay. Each region has its own signature taste and style.
\
Vintage (year) – Especially for reds, the year can change the wine’s personality. Younger wines are often more fruity in flavor and brighter in color, while older vintages develop deeper, more complex notes like leather, earth, or spice.
\
Alcohol level (ABV) – The percentage of alcohol affects how the wine feels. Higher ABV (14% and above) wines will taste warmer, heavier, and more powerful, while lower ABV wines (11–12%) usually feel lighter, fresher, and easier to drink.
\
Body, tannins, acidity – These elements shape the structure of wine. Menus may describe them as light, medium, or full-bodied, dry, oaky, fruity, or crisp and fresh. Knowing these terms helps you imagine the wine before tasting it.
\
By the glass / half-bottle options – Ideal when you want to try different styles, pair each course with something unique.
\
Sommelier’s picks or hidden finds – These sections often hide the best balance between quality and price, highlighting bottles the sommelier personally recommends.
\
Bottle vs retail price – Markups are typical in restaurants, but keep in mind: the gap between restaurant and shop prices can be 2–4 times. It doesn’t always mean the wine is “better”.
\
Food pairings – Some menus suggest which wine goes with which dish. Don’t ignore these notes: a well-chosen pairing can elevate both the food and the wine, making the experience more memorable.
If you keep these details in mind, a wine list suddenly becomes much less intimidating and much easier to navigate.
Good to Know: Cheaper wines are often “punished” with higher percentage markups, especially in the U.S. Restaurants rely on their popularity and the fact that many guests don’t track retail prices.
On the other hand, expensive bottles may carry a prestige surcharge, reflecting not just quality but also the cultural perception that the pricier, the more special.
There’s also a cultural factor. In countries with deep wine traditions like Italy, France, or Spain, wine is more affordable, menus feel more “everyday,” and wine is integrated into daily meals.
In the U.S., however, restaurant wine is often viewed as an elite component of the dining experience, which allows venues to charge higher prices.
I noticed this myself when comparing menus in Europe and the U.S. The same wine can feel casual in Italy but premium in California
💡 Why Napa wines are always pricey
Napa Valley has limited vineyard land, high production costs, and a reputation as one of the top wine regions in the world. Add to this the factor that people associate Napa wines with quality and status, and prices climb even higher. That’s why even mid-range Napa bottles often cost significantly more than comparable wines from other regions.
If you want something Napa-style without the Napa price tag, look for blends from neighboring Sonoma or Paso Robles. They often deliver similar quality at a friendlier price.
🥂 Freshness of Wines Served by the Glass
A glass of wine can be a treat, but only if it’s fresh. Here’s what affects that freshness when ordering by the glass:
Popularity of the wine
If it’s a frequently ordered Sauvignon Blanc or Pinot Grigio, chances are the bottle is opened and finished quickly, so what you get is fresh. Rarely ordered wines may sit open longer.\
Preservation systems
Many restaurants use vacuum pumps, inert gas (argon), or special Coravin systems to keep wines fresh for several days or even weeks.
\
Wine style
Light, crisp whites and sparkling wines lose freshness faster once opened, while fuller reds with tannins or fortified wines can stay vibrant a bit longer.
\
Sommelier’s transparency
Don’t be shy to ask when the bottle was opened. A good sommelier will be happy to tell you and even offer a quick taste to check.
👉 Tip: if you’re unsure about freshness, go for wines that are popular by the glass or ask for the house’s recommendation, they’re likely pouring those more often.
🍮 Dessert & Fortified Wines on the Menu
Is the part of the menu many people skip, but it often hides some of the most memorable wines.
At the end of many wine lists, usually within the dessert menu, you’ll often see a dedicated section for “Dessert & Fortified Wines.” It’s important to know that while they’re listed together, these are not the same type of wine.
Dessert wines (like Sauternes, late-harvest Riesling, or Icewine) are naturally sweet wines with a lower alcohol level, usually around 8–12%. Their sweetness comes from the grapes themselves, whether through late harvest, noble rot, or freezing on the vine. They’re delicate, fruity, and aromatic, pairing beautifully with fruit tarts, light cakes, or creamy desserts.
\
Fortified wines (such as Port, Sherry, Madeira, or Marsala) are made by adding grape spirit during production. This process raises the alcohol content (typically 16–20%) and often leaves both sugar and strength in the wine. They tend to be richer, more intense, with flavors of nuts, caramel, dried fruits, or spice. They are perfect with chocolate, strong cheeses, or nut-based desserts.
Compared to standard wines, both dessert and fortified wines are often sold in smaller bottles (375 ml instead of 750 ml) and poured into smaller glasses. They’re sweeter, more concentrated, and usually enjoyed in small amounts at the end of the meal.
👉 In short: dessert wines highlight sweetness and freshness, while fortified wines combine sweetness with extra power from alcohol. Both can be excellent with dessert, but they create very different experiences.
🍷 7 Extra Tips for a Wine List
Beyond the basics, here are a few extra tips that will make navigating any wine list even easier
Look for seasonal changes
Good restaurants update their wine lists with the seasons, reflecting fresh menus and new vintages.
\
Check the dining style
Some menus are food-first (wine chosen to match dishes), while wine bars may be wine-first (small plates built around the wine).
\
Notice the glassware
The right glass can make a big difference in aroma and taste. It’s a detail worth appreciating.
\
Understand markups in context
Yes, wine costs more in restaurants, but that includes proper storage, service, and the setting that makes the experience special.
\
Ask with confidence
Don’t hesitate to talk to the sommelier. They love guiding guests and can often suggest hidden gems that aren’t obvious on the list.
\
Don’t skip the last section
Wines at the end of the list are often overlooked, yet that’s where you may find rare bottles that turn into the highlight of your evening.\
Go local when you travel
In a new region or city, don’t be afraid to order local wines. They’re often delivered directly from nearby wineries, which means you’ll discover something authentic, delicious, and usually without the heavy markup of imported bottles.
Whether you choose a single glass or share a bottle, the most important thing is that the wine adds joy to your dining experience. Confidence comes not from memorizing every grape, but from knowing that wine is there to be enjoyed.
So take a breath, open the list, and pick with curiosity!
💌 I hope this article was helpful for you. If it was, please share it with your friends, it might make their next wine experience easier too.
Want more delicious discoveries?
Subscribe for free to my newsletter for exclusive wine pairings, dining tips, handpicked recommendations, and the best food and travel finds, all in one place!